Sunday, November 8, 2015

3481  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 06, 2010, 02:20:22 PM
Its wrong to have a theology where repentance is a work. Repentance is the other side of faith. It is given by grace. That means we came into this salvation by grace alone. There was nothing that we offered. Not even our sins or our self will. God had to do an initial work in us in order for us to willingly submit. We were not just sinners but we were blind and helpless. The Spirit had to work conviction in our hearts... different forms in each man... and He did it by showing us our sins and then giving us a new will. He gave us Gods will so that now sin is dead and its only in our identity with Christ that we are enabled. Its no long our dieing for His life. We already died to self. Now learn to trust in and love Christ. Its no longer about us in this sense.

We still are unable in ourselves to do one good thing . Abraham took Isaac up to the alter because he counted himself as wicked. That he might be accepted because he was declared righteous.He was acceptable only because he had an acceptable High Priest. So that all who come to God ... come through the only acceptable sacrifice. Christ. Repentance is a way of life. Its turning to Christ for forgiveness... recognizing that its not our confession that gains us forgiveness but its His active and passive righteousness put to our account. His work alone has gained us acceptance on the day of judgment.

 Just to draw one parallel. We have the same problems with sin that the unbeliever does. And our struggle with sin may be worse than the reprobate. But we have a freedom to deal with sin in contrast. 'If you live by the law you will die by the law.'
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3482  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 06, 2010, 02:00:30 PM
mbG:  "Who can resist His will.(?) "

K_k:  Satan.  And all those God empowers to and allows to reject Him in the end.

mbG:  "Therefore if God is God then He does whatever pleases Him."

K_k:  Yes, and it pleases Him to give us the final choice as to whether we want Him to be our eternal Dad or not.

"This day I call heaven and earth as witnesses against you that I have set before you life and death, blessings and curses. Now choose life, so that you and your children may live."  Deut. 30:19

"But if serving YHWH seems undesirable to you, then choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve, whether the gods your forefathers served beyond the River, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land you are living. But as for me and my household, we will serve YHWH."  Joshua 24:15

In the first case, it is YHWH telling His chosen people to choose.  In the second case, it is Joshua, representing Jesus (same name).

"And it shall come to pass that whoever calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved."  Joel 2:32

"For "whoever calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved." "Romans 10:13

It doesn't say whoever the Lord forces to call on Him shall be saved.  He has the right to say that, of course, but in accordance with the nature of perfect love He gives us the final choice.

Hes talking to His covenant people. Just like in Rev. where He is knocking on the door of the heart. In the context Joshua is asking them to put down the idols.   
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3483  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: What is legalism? on: May 06, 2010, 11:45:11 AM
ERSE 1. And God the Father, who raised him from the dead.

Paul is so eager to come to the subject matter of his epistle, the righteousness of faith in opposition to the righteousness of works, that already in the title he must speak his mind. He did not think it quite enough to say that he was an apostle "by Jesus Christ"; he adds, "and God the Father, who raised him from the dead." The clause seems superfluous on first sight. Yet Paul had a good reason for adding it. He had to deal with Satan and his agents who endeavored to deprive him of the righteousness of Christ, who was raised by God the Father from the dead. These perverters of the righteousness of Christ resist the Father and the Son, and the works of them both. In this whole epistle Paul treats of the resurrection of Christ. By His resurrection Christ won the victory over law, sin, flesh, world, devil, death, hell, and every evil. And this His victory He donated unto us. These many tyrants and enemies of ours may accuse and frighten us, but they dare not condemn us, for Christ, whom God the Father has raised from the dead is our righteousness and our victory.

Do you notice how well suited to his purpose Paul writes? He does not say, "By God who made heaven and earth, who is Lord of the angels," but Paul has in mind the righteousness of Christ, and speaks to the point, saying, "I am an apostle, not of men, neither by man, but by Jesus Christ, and God the Father, who raised him from the dead."Luther
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3484  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 06, 2010, 10:57:51 AM

mbG:  "I know you dont believe if a man has a free will that he is able to resist Gods love. Can you explain to me how a man goes from hating God to loving God without being forced?"

K_k:  I believe that God empowers man to choose a will that resists, and rebels against Him.  And that He does everything He can to maintain our freedom while using conviction, circumstance, people, places and things, to reach out to us in love.  And He is very pursuasive, perfectly pursuasive, as you know.

Yet, no matter how much He shows some people His kindness, compassion and righteousness, they are able to refuse to receive Him or return His love.  This is necessary, i believe, because perfect love can only be given freely, never forced or coerced.  It is for our freedom that He came to earth, and gave His Life, and rose again to give us His Life inside us, upon our invitation to Him to enter our hearts as the Savior He is.

Note that He didn't say He is knocking at the door, and He will break it down if we don't open it.  He allows us to keep it shut, but He doesn't stop knocking until we can no longer open.  And it is He Who empowers us to open without coercing us to do so.

"Here I am! I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears My voice and opens the door, I will come in and eat with him, and he with Me. To him who overcomes, I will give the right to sit with Me on My Throne, just as I overcame and sat down with My Father on His Throne."  Revelation 3:20-21

No one will be able to say, in the Kingdom, that God forced him/her to accept Christ, but we will all be able to say that He drew us, enlightened us, empowered us, to receive Him, and still let us choose whether or not to receive His unending Life as our own.


Who can resist His will. God is eternal. He sees the beginning from the end. His knowledge is the full light of His glory but its darkness to us. God knows everything at one time. Thats why He is most personal to us because He takes into account the knowledge He has of the ends of the earth and judges what is best for us in light of His vision and understanding in all of our cells. If He knows then He desires out of pleasure that it is good. So that God is pleased because He is God in every circumstance and in every space fully worthy of all that He is at all times. Who has known the mind of God ? Who can counsel God? He is from everlasting. His power is unfathomable. How can a man explain about who God is. There are no words for us to describe what is necessary to make men see that God is.
God determines every event in the history of this world. He decrees all the sins of all mankind. God determined to bring His Son into the world before the creation of the world even tho He made man free to choose life and live eternally. Therefore God decreed the first sin of Adam. If God chose for Adam to sin ... and Adam was given the ability not to sin... then we who have no ability to keep from sinning deserve to never do one thing good. We deserve to be eternally punished in hell. But the bible says that God saw us in Christ before the foundation of the world. Nothing takes God by surprise.

Therefore God who is outside of time sees everything that transpires in light of His final judgment. Every man is standing before the tribunal of God outside of time as free as that man is in time. If God declares a man guilty it never was in the mind of God to do otherwise. Because God never changes and whatever He thinks is reality. All of the reality on this earth is designed by God in a thought that is most worthy of the most praise.  The truth is that the time was up when man sinned in the garden. What ever man gets as good from God ...he do not deserve.
If God is free to do as He pleases then we are most free to qualify the truth. If in some way God is determined by something outside of Himself then He can be thwarted in some way. If God can be changed in some way then that way is according to the understanding of someone outside of God. If a thousand people determined how God is to be changed then there are a thousand ways in which God is not God. Therefore if God is God then He does whatever pleases Him.
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3485  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Hidden In God on: May 06, 2010, 09:46:30 AM
This way is a way of grace. This is why we should not be quick to judge. Because we live with a level of our own weakness that defines how God is going to meet us at the cross roads of our sin and His grace. This is why it is dangerous to listen to the counsel of the world. Because there are some things that we focus on that will add more grief than we can handle.
All of our sin is because there is some corruption in all of our parts. Sometimes we think that God is exposing our pain in order to deflect the pleasure we get in sinning. But God determines how the path that we learn in the way of our own weakness. In other words the reason that we are gaining pleasure out of our sin is because God is making us not trust in our own ability to our joy. He wants us to find our comfort from our sins in His mercy. But there are many problems that we have in this life and we are always searching for a solution that we think God is trying to work in us at the present time.
We fail to see that Gods time table is not like ours. This is why our lives must be hidden in God. Because there is a lot of counsel that will take us on long rabbit trails. There are many evil intentions for men to draw other men into their particular bondage and at the same time do it for the purposes of dealing with us in our own sins. But we fail to hold onto the hope we had at the beginning. We are not seeking to lose our lives to find our security in God alone. But we are trading our pleasure for sin and in place we are being subject to the bondage of men. And in the end we will find that sin has more pleasure than the one that God was using to humble us and keep us on the path of learning.
We must see that our big problem is that we try to change our most insecure areas by the flesh because we feel the guilt of our sins. God deals with us in a way that His grace is giving us a sense of freedom in falling in order for us to find a peace that will keep us from utterly falling. When we find that we are searching these things out for reasons that are not entirely under the disposition of free grace then we are in danger of forgetting where we came from. We loose connection with the Head.
We will always persevere through our own sins and find grace to help us in our time of need. The grace gives us the motive to keep from trusting in our working for a payment in order to move down this path. Men who are self righteous will be full of warnings and distresses in order to get us to take our eyes off  of Christ. Sometimes its best for us to struggle with sin and find that it is not as pleasurable as we thought the end would be. Then we will find that God loves us in a way that He is building in us a strong sense of repentance to sin because His way is greater than sin. Love always wins. This is seeking to be hidden in God.     
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3486  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Hidden In God on: May 06, 2010, 08:57:14 AM
Uncompromising is essential as a way of being alone in this protection. This battle is in the causes of the general direction of the way people express their power in their love for idols. The opposition is the evil that is working in the sons of disobedience. This opposition as a cause is in the desires of evil men. This is where all of the disconnection and confusion are expressed in the weight of pain in which tyranny flourishes. If evil men get their way then they will destroy the righteous. We are dealing with a very formatable enemy of our personal well being. Because there is a direct influence to us in how we determine these sorrows in our own souls. We are always in danger of depending on our own strength to acquire a peace not realizing that it demands impersonal paradigms in our view as we look beyond our general level of sorrow. Because God hardens in a destructive way in order to oppose.

This is why things work backwards as we react to these circumstances in our persevering spirit. What is needed is not desired by rebels. But what is appreciated is what the righteous acquire in swallowing up the desires of the wicked. In other words there is a righteous anger in the way of finding all things to fall into place. Because the desires of the righteous are made sure by bringing these good things into reality by a source that is outside of themselves. So that on the one hand there is always a general tendency in a future desire to be fulfilled ....for a person to lose heart in the perseverance.. and on the other hand to succumb to the fear of man. This is why we find that the battle has the experience of being spiritually assaulted. In other words we must deal with the opposition in the spiritual realm in order to find the spiritual desire come to reality.   
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3487  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Why do our opinions differ? on: May 06, 2010, 05:46:41 AM
Since no one seemed to respond to this before I figured I would bring it to the fore again.


People are interesting...

If they say something like "sola scriptura" then that theoretically would mean that the bible is self explanatory. Sometimes it is. sometimes it isn't. at times where it isn't I believe one should go back to the culture that the Book came out of in order to understand it better.

otherwise if one assumes that the bible can explain itself and tries not to use any other tradition or culture to help interpret then they will fall prey to their own perspective which is not right. "your thoughts are not My thoughts neither are My thoughts your thoughts"

An amendment and correction to this quote from my memory of the Scripture:

Your thoughts are not my thoughts neither are My WAYS your ways.
"lean not on your own understanding"

Yet one should not only do what I have described above but also one should take advantage of the teacher that G-d has sent to us. THS.


Matthew 4:4
Jesus answered, "It is written: 'Man does not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God.' " Gods provision of food is common...but spiritual food is absolutely necessary for the whole man. Since Gods word determines events then nothing exist apart from His will. He is the cause of all of the vitality of life.. all other beings are subject to death. Gods revelation is who He is as eternally present. Our problems are not our knowledge of that word but it is believing that it defines all the future events in our lives. When we steal a false image of His reality we decide to determine our own pathway.  

MBG... while I agree with you that Scripture MUST be the final standard, in order to UNDERSTAND it, one must sometimes resort to the very culture that gave birth to the MEN who were inspired to write what is written! What it is all about is language issues combined with deception of the Enemy.
That is why one needs BOTH a clear understanding of the Culture the Bible came out of (which was and is Jewish) AND THS. Without the Jewish factor into the equation one MIGHT be able to discern what was originally meant. Yet it makes it a LOT easier to just do a comparison to the idioms used in Hebrew.

For Example:
========================================================================
Psalm 122 CJB

1  A song of ascents. By David: I was glad when they said to me, "The house of ADONAI! Let's go!"  2  Our feet were already standing at your gates, Yerushalayim.  3  Yerushalayim, built as a city fostering friendship and unity.  4  The tribes have gone up there, the tribes of ADONAI, as a witness to Isra'el, to give thanks to the name of ADONAI.  5  For there the thrones of justice were set up, the thrones of the house of David.  6  Pray for shalom in Yerushalayim; may those who love you prosper.7  May shalom be within your ramparts, prosperity in your palaces.  8  For the sake of my family and friends, I say, "Shalom be within you!"  9  For the sake of the house of ADONAI our God, I will seek your well-being.  
=========================================================================
Now verse 6 is a COMMONLY MISINTERPRETED verse.

The word in Hebrew translated as "Pray" is the Word used in Hebrew for "asking" something.

now does that make sense in English? Of course not.

Yet in Hebrew the idiom Ma sh'lomcha (how is your peace) is VERY common both in Biblical times and today.

The Hebrew word for prayer that I am familiar with most is "teffilah". Check out the Strongs if you doubt me:
=========================================================================
The KJV Old Testament Hebrew Lexicon

 Strong's Number:   07592   
Original Word   Word Origin
laX   a primitive root
Transliterated Word   TDNT Entry
Sha'al   TWOT - 2303
Phonetic Spelling   Parts of Speech
shaw-al'        Verb
 Definition

   1. to ask, enquire, borrow, beg
         1. (Qal)
               1. to ask, ask for
               2. to ask (as a favour), borrow
               3. to enquire, enquire of
               4. to enquire of, consult (of deity, oracle)
               5. to seek
         2. (Niphal) to ask for oneself, ask leave of absence
         3. (Piel)
               1. to enquire, enquire carefully
               2. to beg, practise beggary
         4. (Hiphil)
               1. to be given on request
               2. to grant, make over to, let (one) ask (successfully) or give or lend on request (then) grant or make over to


 King James Word Usage - Total: 173
ask 94, enquire 22, desire 9, require 7, borrow 6, salute 4, demand 4, lent 4, request 3, earnestly 2, beg 2, miscellaneous 16
 ==========================================================================

Now the Hebrew idiom is a  request to the reader, not to pray per se (though it certainly isn't WRONG to pray for Jerusalem), but to personally ask Jerusalem herself "How is your peace" or more in English Idiom "how are you, Jerusalem?" to express interest in the welfare of someone... in this case Jerusalem.

This interpretation makes more sense given the context of the Psalm. For later in the same Psalm it is said "may those who love you prosper." Love is an action. Not a simple putting of it off on G-d to look out for Jerusalem but to Actively ask the welfare of Jerusalem and seek to meet those needs. To put action behind one's words. "Faith without works is DEAD"... James I believe...

Shalom to MBG and ALL others.


Thanks Daveed... you know more about the culture than i do. That is true what you say. But there is a much deeper spiritual dimension going on here. Jerusalem was where the temple worship took place. It was where the presence of God dwelt in the Holy of Holies. The shekinah glory. This was the City of God. There are parallels drawn in this local dwelling with a universal existence in lite of this glory. So that the vast dimensions were represented in the value of the local worship. In other words God dwelt in Jerusalem but His glory extended unto the whole earth. Or it is eternal.
This vision was prophetic as well as covenantal. In a sense the covenant was represented as a longing by confessing. "May my rite hand forget its skill  if I do not consider Jerusalem my highest joy." So goes worshiping Yahweh ... so goes Jerusalem. So goes Jerusalem ... so goes the experience of dwelling in peace. If God was worshiped correctly then the city was Gods city. It was a city of blessing.
This is why in my 20 yrs of meditation on Davids Psalms i cant separate that historical setting from my understanding of this earthly connection to how Jerusalem has effected every culture in the NT sense. And yet i have never traveled to Jerusalem. Maybe my vision is that God developed this culture in a sense of the linage of freedom that extended in its influence to my country. i do not think we can divorce our natural longings for the welfare of our own culture with that historical setting. Thats why just like God creating the earth ... it will not be utterly destroyed... so God will return to His people one day. I dont know the details.

Even in the taking of oaths was centered around this earthly ruler ship. Gods relationship with His people was explained in His covenant promises. All of His focus was on this active communication of His protection... His restoration.. His discipline ... and His reminders of past deliverance. This is expressed in a Fatherly concern to uphold the individual posterity to be a blessing to the whole earth. Gods love is not just some kind of direct supernatural intervention. But it is creating new life so that the principles of freedom extend through each mans heritage. I mean in the sense of showing Gods covenant faithfulness in these families of true worshipers. This is the culture of private property... individual rites etc.
This is why in putting these longings into mens hearts there are a mixture of natural longings and supernatural longings. Every man desires the holistic view of having a connection in his personal survival in both a national spirit and a salvific understanding as it relates to being in exile. I do not think we can figure out this individual paradigm as it is expressed differently in each person. This represents our struggle with individual frustrations and how we are going to experience a sense of inward freedom. This is why these things cannot be made to work properly in seeking them directly. But we must have a God centered way of life in the natural created order. In finding God all things are set in order.    
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3488  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Hidden In God on: May 06, 2010, 05:15:11 AM
http://www.oneplace.com/ministries/living-grace/listen/
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3489  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Hidden In God on: May 04, 2010, 08:04:09 PM
Our problems are sorrows that pierce our hearts. Because the soul has enemies that are not physical. These enemies are hidden behind appearances of good relationships that we make in this world. Because we only have one allegiance. Most of our relational pressures comes from a direct assault on our deep inward dependence on God. We hardly ever deal with a direct assault. But these kinds of things come through words and a general intent to oppose us.Most of the time we are like the frog in a pan... we just retreat into our christian shell.

 Now this can become a very big struggle with sorrow. Because after awhile we find that our love for God is almost gone. This is why we have traitors in our souls. They are not even from personal sins. They come into us through opposition. One of the hardest realities to deal with is how we think the bible tells us to act as christians. We think it is saying that we are required to receive this opposition into our souls because we must deny ourselves. In other words the message is that it does not matter how we are treated just as long as we show love. Well the devil is not going to stop accusing us because we are so kind and loving. He is like a roaring lion who is very hungry. So he is going to attack our faith.. it may be through a physical trauma or it may be through words. But we can be sure that any time we lose a sense of the majesty and glory of God it is because there are subversive tactics that we are always going to face.
This is why our fight is against forces of evil in heavenly places. These are oppositions that get us to have an image of God that turns us to be angry at God. This is why we must not only guard our hearts but we must fight for our one love. We must cast down... that is make an effort to curse these enemies. We are human beings who have very difficult experiences. The bible tells us to continue in the faith. We sometimes are so numb that it seems like that we are just holding on.. not even thinking about faith. We must arouse ourselves. We must engage ourselves in prayer in a fight. We must seek for our first love even if we have been opposed so that we are full of sorrow. It is our responsibility to seek out these invisible foes. That is wisdom applied to the soul. Not only should we ask God for wisdom but we must use the tools of the word to expose the lies of our thinking.

Pray sometimes is like chopping down a tree. We attack the doubts with the word. We attack the opposition with prayer. Just as Jesus did in the garden. He was praying and sweating drops of blood. The Lord heard His prayer and saved Him from a kind of death. He was praying the Psalms with more passion than any man could produce. He not only worked up a sweat but His prayers were so intense that the blood came through His pores. His prayers gave Him strength to continue on to the cross.     
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3490  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Hidden In God on: May 04, 2010, 05:10:10 PM
We are seeking the living God. We have new desires that not only draw us to worship God but they hold us in this refuge. These desires are inter mingled with our physical senses. This is represented as our having an unnatural joy mixed with the sorrows we encounter in having to deal with fleeting thoughts and desires. Because there are some things in this world that only bring a temporary pleasure... there are some things that tempt us to wrong attitudes... and there are threats to our general welfare. And we are always susceptible to try and find our answers in this world counsel. Because we are social beings and we are mixed in our longings for things and people to fill up our feelings of loneliness.

This is why there are things in this world that create the ideas in which we find temporary answers. There are good things to think about but there is a tendency to place them as more important than they are. We are caught in between these two worlds and our survival is determined by our growing in wisdom so that we might know the difference. This is why we must find all of our security in our God. Because there are things that are too weighty in this world for us to handle. They would bring us under a very strong struggle with sorrow and fear.

Most all of the problems we encounter in this life are from times where we got caught off guard in a general lethargic kind of religious experience. We are susceptible as Gods people to be attacked from both extremes. On the one hand we have these deep needs that create in us much turmoil if not met. On the other hand we have a temptation to search for success at the expense of our spiritual and physical health. This is why we cant trust our physical senses in judging the good or evil that comes to us. This is why our lives must be hidden in God.

Because when we are seeking to find refuge in God then we become relaxed and satisfied. This is why dependence should be our most profound experience. God is full of grace. The grace that He gives keeps us from sin and temptation.. it keeps us from abandoning Him when we struggle with a sin.. and it becomes to us an indispensable property of our souls. We must have grace or we will be sorrowful.

 This is why dependence has this overlapping attraction to drawing nearer to our Father. In calling on our Father we gain more of His adequacy to keep seeking Him. Grace is a new ability we receive to find all of our confidence in the newness of our fellowship ing with Him. We are drawing near to our Father who keeps us from the fatal blow on the day of battle by arming us with the helmet of salvation. He actually speaks the world of salvation in our future deliverance. Grace is infused to us in particular situations as giving us a longing hope to hear the word spoken to us.Now let me say that over a period of time if we have been used to listening to Him... we actually hear a whole lot of His voice. I cant tell at this point if its an illumination or if its just like a preacher telling me something. I mean.. here we are walking around and then we get this strong influence that comes over us and then we are hearing Him tell us what is going on. I had the Spirit tell me the other day about my son of whom i did not say the word I received in speaking to him but he told me exactly what the Spirit has said ten minutes prior after i had asked him an indirect question. Then i assure him. After 30 yrs of meditation i get a constant communication from heaven.    

 
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3491  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Praying in the Spirit on: May 04, 2010, 03:36:33 PM
We have this implantation of new life. Now this is by experience as well. When we are thinking about implanting we are talking about a very connective thing to the elements of all that produces this life. So we are not just dealing with the initial Spirit connection here. But we have a soil about our souls. We are receiving these other elements that give us a curtain opposition to our general growth. These things are primarily our experience of all that we contact in our humanity. So that the general sorrow or frustrations we experience have an effect on the flow of that life. Which produces a general lethargic process in not only our spiritual exuberance but also our emotional and physical expression. We were made to enjoy God and it includes our soul enjoyment. Or our specific human tendencies to enjoyment.
This is having a quality of fellowship with the Spirit. Now our prayers are formed in this new focus. So that we begin to see things with the eyes of faith and we communicate as if these spiritual sustenance's that sustain life become a kind of physical interaction. We live before God in our understanding of receiving this implantation in a holistic fashion. Our communication in our prayers are interrelated with our humanity. That is unless we begin to deal with our own ability to know the difference between having an unrelated anxiety because of a mysterious weight upon our souls that we do not identify in our prayers then we cannot wrestle in the way of implanting in the spiritual understanding of this fellowship through our natural longings.
This is why the word has these different cries of the heart as the influence of this life of implantation. Because in that cry there is a renewed effect that determines the deep level of fellowship in our own humanity in His receiving us as His children. We are learning to unburden these weights in a way that we grow in recognizing how we receive these things into our souls with our general tendencies as we were made. The Holy Spirit is as personal to us as our prayers are for other people. Now then that is what we are learning in this tendency to be subverted in receiving that new life that other people could receive in our prayers.   
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3492  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 04, 2010, 02:05:56 PM
mbG:  "God did not determine to open our eyes because He saw something that we could do for Him."

K_k:  He knew, in His foreknowledge, those who would become able to let Him open their eyes, with His love, yet without forcing, or coercing, them open. And they/we are the ones destined to be like Him.

"Don’t you see how wonderfully kind, tolerant, and patient God is with you? Does this mean nothing to you? Can’t you see that His kindness is intended to turn you from your sin?"  Romans 2:4 NLT

"For whom He foreknew, He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, that He might be the firstborn among many brethren." Romans 8:29

mbG: "In other words there is only one love that is true. It is eternal and comes into time. It comes from a source that is love. If God is love then love is God."

K_k:  A lot of truth there, but the last sentence is misleading.  Only Agape' (in Greek), perfect love is God.  All lower forms of what we call "love", in English, are not necessarily from Him.  We probably need a completely different word for His extremely pure love, as the more precise Greek language had.

mbG:  "God loves because He is love not because He sees something to love."

K_k:  God sees something to love because perfect love creates living beings to love.  Love is about intimate relationship.

May i imagine you agree with my 'nit-pick'?

Quote
K_k:  He knew, in His foreknowledge, those who would become able to let Him open their eyes, with His love, yet without forcing, or coercing, them open. And they/we are the ones destined to be like Him.
Kk... coercing someone is forcing them to do something against their will. I know you dont believe if a man has a free will that he is able to resist Gods love. Can you explain to me how a man goes from hating God to loving God without being forced?

I can give you what the scripture says.
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3493  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 04, 2010, 01:28:59 PM
Kk... we all make deals with God. If you save me from this situation then i will do this and that. I give you this and you will make me a better christian. But that is not the real God. God did not determine to open our eyes because He saw something that we could do for Him. Do you know that God never made a deal with any one? He saved some men and saw that they needed to be carried. Thats why He is the great Shepard. Because He carries us from one wandering place to another.
The only reason that people think to be moral is to make deals and keep them is because they think that it will satisfy their sense of equality. The truth is that no man can determine what is equal. Taint one man that has ever been satisfied with the returns on his deal! Because the universe is not a real image of true worth. Thats why love is unattainable by works. Because once you make a demand on being loved then you must love perfectly. Because love can only be love when it has no standards to love. It loves from a realistic view of eternal love. This is why love is communicated because it is condescending.
In other words there is only one love that is true. It is eternal and comes into time. It comes from a source that is love. If God is love then love is God. God loves because He is love not because He sees something to love. God loves out of total freedom to love. If a person was to have a life where he received a communication of love it would be from God without any requirements. It would be a full expression of all that comes in feeling worthy in always being loved no matter what. This is why these ideas that we are getting from St Thomas and Austin... are so important. Now i give you something to think about here. Look what the apostle says about Gods work. Some mind twisting concepts to ponder.
Romans 11
35"Who has ever given to God,
      that God should repay him?"[k]
 36For from him and through him and to him are all things.
      To him be the glory forever! Amen.    
3496  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Free writing on: May 04, 2010, 12:11:22 PM

Yeah, i got a little irritated about such a flow of ideas that looks like it came from a dark part of a confused soul, under the guise of "deep thought".  I suppose i should have kept my prodigious mouth shut, but sometimes i like to flap the lips randomly and see what comes out.  (Not speaking in tongues, or anything like that....)

Anyway, your last statement "I mean if God is the subject then He is His own object in essence.  He is the cause of all that exists...as expressed through the will of man", doesn't connect with me.

To say He is His own object would seem to make all objects God.  Not so.  He is Holy in the highest sense which includes being separate from His creation, while interpenetrating it.  He is not the direct cause of all that exists, but allows secondary causes, like man's will and/or satan's actions, to be temporary subjects causing temporary actions on temporary objects.

Say, what was i irritated for?  Word games can be fun.  

Kk i did not say other objects were His object. I am simply saying that God is only pleased in His own image of Himself. There is nothing good outside of God. I think i will bring the Edwards article .. the "End for which God created the world."
I do not think that ideas are dangerous in themselves. I dont think we disagree that in seeking wisdom we must seek knowledge. Its like looking for a hidden treasure. Because God is predominately a teacher who has a principle that all truth is in His truth. I mean... frustration is not a process that we draw an analogy in which our approach to truth is what makes it evil. If it is true and we are corrupted then we are on the road to transformation. If it is not true then our own desire to make it true is not Gods way to truth. The old saying is if i dont know i am saved there is nothing that will help me except seeking the gospel.
Well , there are many sorrows in this world that we find have a way of filling up in our humanity. We are kind of like empty vessels who receive these sorrows as human beings. When Epaphroditus was sorrowful and sick the apostle sent him back to his home because He was home sick. Paul recognized that there are times when we must be sensitive to the general condition of a person as it relates to his strengths and weaknesses. We always want to bring a person to rejoice in God and not to focus on a persons sorrows. This is why we cannot redefine the process of transformation. We are mostly teachers and not fruit inspectors. I mean... we are simply showing a beggar how to find bread ... not adding more burdens to them than they can handle. Sometimes it best to overlook peoples foibles in order to save them from much sorrow. This is the gospel approach. Stay away from people who think that it is always correct to tell people they have cancer ... some people need to be loved by giving them hope and not necessarily the truth. The old saying is ... if you havent walked in my shoes then keep your mouth shut.

In dealing with these sensitive areas of people it is not our position to move this process along. Because there is a sense in which our personal involvement could produce a disastrous outcome so that it becomes something that we must deal with in our own minds for the rest of our lives on this earth. There are reasons why God leads every person on a different path as a general focus of a teacher. If God could enable everyone to face all of the problems of this life then He is the only one who has the rite to determine how much they are required to carry. If He gave us that responsibility then we would need to measure our ability to enable someone with our lack of understanding in making them sorrowful. That would mean that we are culpable in the outcome. Who wants to have that reality facing them? Paul did not return to every family he destroyed in his former life and apologize. In fact he made it an issue of the gospel to say that he did not have the blood of any mans hands on him. So that judicial qualifications are in light of Gods grace even on this earth. That means that Paul did not follow the sermon on the mount as a law. Be careful in how you view counsel. I would be very observant of a man who did not have a full understanding of these counseling ways of the Psalms. They are the idea paradigms of the gospel counsel in which they create a basis for super naturalistic living. They divide the true from the false in paradigm form. If you are in this business and have the ability.... i would counsel you to memorize this book.  
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3497  Forums / Theology Forum / Hidden In God on: May 04, 2010, 11:10:54 AM
 We are seeking to leave this world for a time. The way to spiritual transformation is treating this world as a fickle friend. Its seeing with spiritual eyes. We live a life of faith... the world wants us to live by sight. Faith is something that we acquire by a gift. We can not find it in any other connection on this earth. It comes to us directly. I mean faith as defining our better view of things.
We are walking down this long hall way. The world is at our backs. We are fleeing this world because it is cursed. We see the blessings of all of the good things in another world. Every cursed spirit is trying to force us into a connection to this world that would hold us in its power. We are free people. The world is a world of bondage. Thats why we groan inwardly. Because the world swallows people up into its system with the Prince and power of the air and it draws people into powers that are seducing. It makes a man focus on things that are in close connection to an impossible set of standards. Because the world offers a wage for a payment. You pay with your life and you get a measly wage. In the world there is no such thing as eternity. It is who gets the most toys wins. These massive wages hold men under the power of their own lust! But  comparative to the wages of eternity they are miserly.

 So that we always want to get out of this world in order to be free to live in another world. We long to see Jesus. So we groan in a way that we would flee to our mountain and these mountains of reality are actual views we have of not being under the domination of men or things even tho they try to force us to feel a certain way in the transaction. We are living a life of no condemnation.

That is why we belong to another world. Because the men in this world look at us and they say.. you cannot possibly be realistic in your being poor in this world. You are a dunce. To which we say... How can you shake your finger in the face of God? Now i tell you with all of my heart... seek His face ... flee from the wrath to come! You have no power over my life... it is hidden in God! When we see our Kings face then the light of the glory of God... that which is more valuable than anything in this world.. it shines in our faces. It makes our countenance unlike anything transparent in this world! This is why when we call on our great deliver from the world we receive better than we could ever ask or think. The world offers wages that are burdens... God gives us things that are beyond our pay scale! Is your life hidden in God? Do you feel like a foreigner in this world? Are you all alone in God?
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3498  Forums / Main Forum / Re: Titus 2:15 on: May 04, 2010, 10:18:38 AM
Here is where i think the confusion is. Its public and private practice. When we live in private we are not necessarily focusing on the rite things. The private practice is trying to develop a world view where we see everything in this universe as either glorifying God or dethroning God. Again... its not the appearance before men. Its gaining wisdom in the use of the means so that in keeping this discernment we say things in our private prayers that we discern in public. So we try to keep peace in public and we get real honest before God in private. Because all of these things in christain community are done in the use of the means. The problem is that we do not know how to use these discerning things in a way that helps us deal with them on another level in private. Thats why it gets so political.

We are looking into a deeper level of the dynamic of life. Every person who lives from one yr to another develops his own view of things as a matter of the causes of his own spiritual dynamic. So that its not what we see or what we try to do in our connecting with one another. Its a mindset that produces a level of understanding over a persons life. Thats why there is a distinct enjoyment of a believer that is not of this world. In other words our lives become hidden in Him over a period of time. This is why every thing about the christian society is backwards. Because the fake people have spent their lives seeking after self righteousness. These traits of meanness and unloving communication are traits of an accusatory paradigm. Thats why you cant fake this growing love. It overcomes ... not in a perfect way... but in a way of over looking the sins in others. A person who lives life with a humanistic political relational mindset will deal with every thing about truth in lite of the modern philosophies of this world. We are dealing with two very distinct pathways.     
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3499  Forums / Main Forum / Re: Titus 2:15 on: May 04, 2010, 10:04:37 AM
It is an impossible task for anyone to do in their own strength. Because there is a fine line between political maneuvering and real healing. Thats why the section starts off with the importance of the doctrinal focus. I mean if we just dealt with each other in a way of site, or listening, or having a feeling of things then it would not be a holistic definition of unity. There are some very simple things. One is a persons understanding of the doctrines. Are these doctrines alive in the people. That is a matter of how they communicate about these things. It is not the same in everyone because everyone is not able to articulate these things but you can get to the bottom of what they trust in as knowing and seeing how much time they invest in seeking these things. "Those who seek me will find Me"

Its just like marriage. If you live with a person for any length of time you can see because you are there 24 hrs. So you know what they value. You watch them pursue knowledge ... pursue wisdom.. pursue relationships... you know them. A person can be the most giving person in the world. They can extend their hand to the poor. They can teach children. They can do all the good works that we think a person should be doing and still be as spiritually blind as a mass murderer. Although they should get their rewards in this life. But it is all political. This is why it is so difficult to be in this spiritual leadership. Cause in this kind of society the people who look the most righteous may be the people who are the actors.
This society is made up of people who are totally opposite of other people. In christian community there is no such thing as psychological profiles. There are the saints and the aints.That means the saints have it better than they could ever imagine and the aints have it worse than they ever imagine. But what we have here is an appearance of righteousness. Its is made up of the most subversive spirits. We have everyone confessing and acknowledging. But not everyone is in the thing like it looks. Those who are in dont always look like they are in and those who are out hardly ever look like they are out. So that if we are not wise we may be encouraging those who are out to continue to be out by their appearance.   
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3500  Forums / Main Forum / Re: Titus 2:15 on: May 04, 2010, 09:36:05 AM
Titus 2
What Must Be Taught to Various Groups
 1You must teach what is in accord with sound doctrine. 2Teach the older men to be temperate, worthy of respect, self-controlled, and sound in faith, in love and in endurance.

 3Likewise, teach the older women to be reverent in the way they live, not to be slanderers or addicted to much wine, but to teach what is good. 4Then they can train the younger women to love their husbands and children, 5to be self-controlled and pure, to be busy at home, to be kind, and to be subject to their husbands, so that no one will malign the word of God.

 6Similarly, encourage the young men to be self-controlled. 7In everything set them an example by doing what is good. In your teaching show integrity, seriousness 8and soundness of speech that cannot be condemned, so that those who oppose you may be ashamed because they have nothing bad to say about us.

 9Teach slaves to be subject to their masters in everything, to try to please them, not to talk back to them, 10and not to steal from them, but to show that they can be fully trusted, so that in every way they will make the teaching about God our Savior attractive.

 11For the grace of God that brings salvation has appeared to all men. 12It teaches us to say "No" to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, 13while we wait for the blessed hope—the glorious appearing of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, 14who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.

 15These, then, are the things you should teach. Encourage and rebuke with all authority. Do not let anyone despise you.

This section is talking about how the doctrines of grace are worked out in community. The grace of God is free and able to help people persevere through anything in this life. This grace is not primarily contentious.Teaching is mostly encouraging and strengthening with very little confrontation. If you look at the love chapter in Cor. you will see that Gods love is always gracious and demands us to form relationships in order to deal with each other in a gracious way. Even when you go to the areas where the apostle is talking about discipline it is always done with the full support of everyone. The whole point of gospel encouragement is that there is nothing that is big enough for anyone in way of condemning or slandering. Because it is Gods church. Every thing done from a wrong continuous spirit in a continuous way will defile the spirit of grace. Grace and the law do not mix. The law does not bring ability but it brings a curse. Grace is something that only God can produce in an impossible situation. This is why it teaches us to deny ungodliness. If we stray from the doctrine then we could possibly have a community that practices these godly traits out of fear of consequences. But you cant pass grace up in comparison. Grace is really that which produces all the good in this world. That is why a persons understanding of the doctrines of grace must not be mixed with a (human teaching.- my metaphor for American brand professionalism)

Let no one despise you." Let" is not "demand". That means there is a focus in a way of leading that must not be side tracked. The context is what Christ has done. It is keeping to your identity in His work.
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3501  Forums / Prayer Requests / Re: Please pray for my church... Avalon Presby PCA on: May 02, 2010, 08:19:55 PM
There is definitely a very special season here. I will remember Pastor Jim Fitzgerald when its his time to go.  Praying for success all around.
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3502  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Free writing on: May 02, 2010, 03:06:30 PM
Ugh, so much idea diarrhea.  But i can't seem to restrain myself, mbG, so here goes the itty-bitty-picky mental machine.  (Whose analysis was it following the objections? Aquinas?)

"Objection 1: It seems that essence and existence are not the same in God."

K_k:  The existence of God cannot be separated from the essence of God.  His existence cannot be separated from His essence.  The quote by the author is not from the Bible, since there is no Scripture that would divide these aspects from each other, in Him.

"Objection 2: Further, we can know "whether" God exists as said above (Q[2], A[2]); but we cannot know "what" He is."

K_k:  We can know what God is to the degree He has revealed Himself to us, in the Scriptures.  He is Spirit.  And Love.  And Light.  And Truth.  And Life.  And the Way.  And the Logos/Word.  And the beginning and ending.  And all the Self-revelations we find in His Book.  (Which is not to say we can fully understand any of these in this life/mind.)

"Reply to Objection 2: "To be" can mean either of two things. It may mean the act of essence, or it may mean the composition of a proposition effected by the mind in joining a predicate to a subject. Taking "to be" in the first sense, we cannot understand God's existence nor His essence; but only in the second sense."

K_k: We don't just compose propositions by joining a predicate to a subject in the case of God.  Instead, we have extended detailed descriptions of what each of the predicates look like as His essence in action.  It's called the Bible. 

 

Kk... you seem to be a little irritated. I hope that you will continue to grow in the downloads i put on here. It may seem like its heavy but notin that matters in this world is good unless it brings a man to rejoice in God. And as you know this is bout ideas.
All three of us agree ... Kk St Thomas and little old me. We all agree that God is the same in His essence as presence. But i agree more with Thomas about the subject verb metaphysical logic. The subject determines the action and in this objective lesson of God ... He is what His essence is at all times. Now there is a much deeper argument here. It has to do with a mans self determination. The cause of the action is the subject and not the action itself. This is why there is no such thing as self determination in the equilibrium metaphysical argument. If freedom is represented by the will having two equal choices as the expression then who needs a subject in the sentence?... hehe The subject is the cause of the willing. There is no verb if there is not actual movement toward the object. I mean if God is the subject then He is His own object in essence. He is the cause of all that exist... as expressed though the will of man.
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3503  Forums / Politics Forum / Re: Repentance as a Nation on: May 02, 2010, 01:55:30 PM
Psalm 44
For the director of music. Of the Sons of Korah. A maskil. [a]
 1 We have heard with our ears, O God;
       our fathers have told us
       what you did in their days,
       in days long ago.
2 With your hand you drove out the nations
       and planted our fathers;
       you crushed the peoples
       and made our fathers flourish.
3 It was not by their sword that they won the land,
       nor did their arm bring them victory;
       it was your right hand, your arm,
       and the light of your face, for you loved them.
4 You are my King and my God,
       who decrees victories for Jacob.
5 Through you we push back our enemies;
       through your name we trample our foes.
6 I do not trust in my bow,
       my sword does not bring me victory;
Here is the acknowledgment that our hope is not in the endurance of a nation. Because God gifts us with all of these societies of peace and in His time He destroys them. It is freeing to know that even our own history was given to us by God in grace. We had nothing to do with it in a real sense ! God is the cause of all good things in our experience! And He gives us a return not based upon our performance.
7 but you give us victory over our enemies,
       you put our adversaries to shame.
8 In God we make our boast all day long,
       and we will praise your name forever.
       Selah
9 But now you have rejected and humbled us;
       you no longer go out with our armies.
This is the national rejection of God. Its from a wicked generation. Although the redeemed do not experience a direct assault on their faith in experiencing this rejection as personal, yet there is much distress. This is a very real experience according to our humanity. We are encouraged to pour out our troubles to our loving heavenly Father who orders all of these national rejections for our good.

10 You made us retreat before the enemy,

       and our adversaries have plundered us.
They actually came into the country and destroyed all of the belongings of the ot church. They experienced the exile. This was a national judgment by God and it was like experiencing a real sudden disaster.
11 You gave us up to be devoured like sheep
       and have scattered us among the nations.
12 You sold your people for a pittance,
       gaining nothing from their sale.
Wow this is amazing. Here the monies and the their livelihood for the exchange were wasted at the expense of  Gods people. Uh.. does this look familiar? They took the lively hood of Gods people and it was not even returned. It was wasted.

13 You have made us a reproach to our neighbors,
       the scorn and derision of those around us.
14 You have made us a byword among the nations;
       the peoples shake their heads at us.
They lost their respect as a nation among the other nations. Now this is most humbling. You talk about a massive rejection!

15 My disgrace is before me all day long,
       and my face is covered with shame
16 at the taunts of those who reproach and revile me,
       because of the enemy, who is bent on revenge.
Listen do not hide your head under the pillow. This is personal! Dont think that it does not have repercussions on all of these personal problems we have with rejection. You will experience a lot of hardness and mental anguish if you ignore these things. It must be poured out to God. The national problems are His communication to the very core of our hearts!
17 All this happened to us,
       though we had not forgotten you
       or been false to your covenant.
18 Our hearts had not turned back;
       our feet had not strayed from your path.
19 But you crushed us and made us a haunt for jackals
       and covered us over with deep darkness.

 20 If we had forgotten the name of our God
       or spread out our hands to a foreign god,

 21 would not God have discovered it,
       since he knows the secrets of the heart?

 We can be confident that God who loves us in a covenant and eternal way has taken care of our sins. The point here is that a christian is very in tune with the state of the world. He is made to be directly involved in this conflict as it becomes his personal temptation! Its not in our ability but its in the struggle.
 22 Yet for your sake we face death all day long;
       we are considered as sheep to be slaughtered.
They were subject to the threats of the dominate rule.

23 Awake, O Lord! Why do you sleep?
       Rouse yourself! Do not reject us forever.

 24 Why do you hide your face
       and forget our misery and oppression?

 25 We are brought down to the dust;
       our bodies cling to the ground.

 26 Rise up and help us;
       redeem us because of your unfailing love.

 Here is the most personal cry from a saint! Here is the true expression of sorrow in a human sense and a dependence on God alone. He promises to hear our cries and takes personal pleasure in coming to our defense. Its living in the sunshine of Gods covenant love! He will never fail those who hope in HIm!

Let me give you a sense of how a person evolves in this kind of feeling that the world is opening up beneath the feet and ready to swallow up our personal comforts . We have always been subject to rejection. Its just that we fail to see that all we have need of is in God alone! This is what strikes us at the heart of our securities. We have drifted so far in our opulence. You see we went from trusting in a patriarchal society and finding comforts in our standard of living that we forgot God. Your desperation for and finding friends is not gong to satisfy you. Your standard of living in this world is scoffed at. Listen these Pharisees and their progressive theology will be a thing of the past when these things get worse. Trust me.  Now the rejection we feel is a pain that we must return to our God. Because unless we find all of our happiness in God then we will always be subject to being restless. Unless we find God we will always be restless.
Our confidence in God is that we will never be shaken! We find that this world is more and more of an assaulting place. They assault our character... they threaten our personal prosperity... they demand things that are impossible to accomplish and they use us to destroy us. But God alone is our reputation! It is His defense of us that we must be made to depend upon. Now its time to see that we who are poor will lose our old self determination. We are not disillusioned. Listen to me... you are not disillusioned. You have the gift of enjoying God. No more temptation... weeeeeeee Because we have all of these defenses at our disposal. We have His word...its an eternal word people. We have prayer... its the most private pleasure that we can develop since we forgot about it. We must go before Him and find real satisfaction. We must seek Him until we silence the old way. Then He will comfort us.  
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3504  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: A Quote on Grace and Free Will... Discuss on: May 02, 2010, 12:47:26 PM
Thor... i am just pointing out these systemic problems in this religious environment.

 Romanticism is not redemption. It is the nice destructive idea. Or it is a teaching with a smile on the face but it is full of malice and destructive subversive principles of oppression. Because romanticism is that art of thinking that looks at these things of the spiritual in a universal view. It is not viewing these destructive tendencies as the subversive act before it is produced in the act itself. Every man who is not familiar with the deception of his own heart as it is controlled by Gods ideas is a romantic at heart.

There is a world of deception in presupposing that the details of this life are un caused. The world is a reality of self determinism. The act of idol worship is in self determinism. Romanticism is treating this as an innocent bystander. Because it is creating the illusion that there are no clear lines in opposing  powers that exist in reality. One mans weakness is another mans reason to do that man harm. This is why the universe is God controlled. God is not romantic but He is determined. The reason that this world is steeped in shallow romanticism is because men do not view the depth of these ideas of the world in contrast to Gods revelation. We live in a world where imaginations are the shaken finger in the face of God.

 This is why we have a refuge that is unlike anything in this world. If people knew how we live in this protective strength that surrounds us on every side they would think that we communicated in a way that was beyond our own understanding of what is real. Because the spiritual world cannot be produced in a human principle. This is a world where all of these ideas are beyond our own pay scale. We are seeing conflicts and future troubles in the real God centered universe of conflict of ideas. Most of the problems we face in this life come from the conflict produced by men in judgmental ism, romanticism, unqualified to be in a position but qualified in the eyes of this romantic world. The world is not just a cesspool of sinfulness and depravity. It is a cursed world. We must seek to go deeper than this romantic convergence of ideas.     
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3505  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Free writing on: May 02, 2010, 11:45:42 AM
Whether essence and existence are the same in God?

Objection 1: It seems that essence and existence are not the same in God. For if it be so, then the divine being has nothing added to it. Now being to which no addition is made is universal being which is predicated of all things. Therefore it follows that God is being in general which can be predicated of everything. But this is false: "For men gave the incommunicable name to stones and wood" (Wis. 14:21). Therefore God's existence is not His essence.

Objection 2: Further, we can know "whether" God exists as said above (Q[2], A[2]); but we cannot know "what" He is. Therefore God's existence is not the same as His essence---that is, as His quiddity or nature.

On the contrary, Hilary says (Trin. vii): "In God existence is not an accidental quality, but subsisting truth." Therefore what subsists in God is His existence.

I answer that, God is not only His own essence, as shown in the preceding article, but also His own existence. This may be shown in several ways. First, whatever a thing has besides its essence must be caused either by the constituent principles of that essence (like a property that necessarily accompanies the species---as the faculty of laughing is proper to a man---and is caused by the constituent principles of the species), or by some exterior agent---as heat is caused in water by fire. Therefore, if the existence of a thing differs from its essence, this existence must be caused either by some exterior agent or by its essential principles. Now it is impossible for a thing's existence to be caused by its essential constituent principles, for nothing can be the sufficient cause of its own existence, if its existence is caused. Therefore that thing, whose existence differs from its essence, must have its existence caused by another. But this cannot be true of God; because we call God the first efficient cause. Therefore it is impossible that in God His existence should differ from His essence. Secondly, existence is that which makes every form or nature actual; for goodness and humanity are spoken of as actual, only because they are spoken of as existing. Therefore existence must be compared to essence, if the latter is a distinct reality, as actuality to potentiality. Therefore, since in God there is no potentiality, as shown above (A[1]), it follows that in Him essence does not differ from existence. Therefore His essence is His existence. Thirdly, because, just as that which has fire, but is not itself fire, is on fire by participation; so that which has existence but is not existence, is a being by participation. But God is His own essence, as shown above (A[3]) if, therefore, He is not His own existence He will be not essential, but participated being. He will not therefore be the first being---which is absurd. Therefore God is His own existence, and not merely His own essence.

Reply to Objection 1: A thing that has nothing added to it can be of two kinds. Either its essence precludes any addition; thus, for example, it is of the essence of an irrational animal to be without reason. Or we may understand a thing to have nothing added to it, inasmuch as its essence does not require that anything should be added to it; thus the genus animal is without reason, because it is not of the essence of animal in general to have reason; but neither is it to lack reason. And so the divine being has nothing added to it in the first sense; whereas universal being has nothing added to it in the second sense.

Reply to Objection 2: "To be" can mean either of two things. It may mean the act of essence, or it may mean the composition of a proposition effected by the mind in joining a predicate to a subject. Taking "to be" in the first sense, we cannot understand God's existence nor His essence; but only in the second sense. We know that this proposition which we form about God when we say "God is," is true; and this we know from His effects (Q[2], A[2]).St Thomas
Remove messageRemove ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3506  Forums / Main Forum / Re: Stephen Hawking Show/nature of everything on: May 02, 2010, 11:25:19 AM
Everything that God creates has a form. That includes all the concepts in the mind of all of mankind. But God does not have a form. If something has a beginning it cannot be God because it changed from a state of non existence to existence. If you look at the forms of things you will see there is nothing identical to another form. This is proof that God exist because there is no explanation of how these individualist characteristics were made. I mean even outside of our new knowledge of genetics and such. A mans inflections etc.

 In order for God to be God He must be eternally present and the same at all times. Because God is not subjected to time. He sees the beginning to the end in the present. He cannot be divided, surprised,nor can any thing good be done outside of His good. Gods works the end for Himself. That is why everything He makes is good.  

"I answer that, God is not only His own essence, as shown in the preceding article, but also His own existence. This may be shown in several ways. First, whatever a thing has besides its essence must be caused either by the constituent principles of that essence (like a property that necessarily accompanies the species---as the faculty of laughing is proper to a man---and is caused by the constituent principles of the species), or by some exterior agent---as heat is caused in water by fire. Therefore, if the existence of a thing differs from its essence, this existence must be caused either by some exterior agent or by its essential principles. Now it is impossible for a thing's existence to be caused by its essential constituent principles, for nothing can be the sufficient cause of its own existence, if its existence is caused. Therefore that thing, whose existence differs from its essence, must have its existence caused by another. But this cannot be true of God; because we call God the first efficient cause. Therefore it is impossible that in God His existence should differ from His essence. Secondly, existence is that which makes every form or nature actual; for goodness and humanity are spoken of as actual, only because they are spoken of as existing. Therefore existence must be compared to essence, if the latter is a distinct reality, as actuality to potentiality. Therefore, since in God there is no potentiality, as shown above (A[1]), it follows that in Him essence does not differ from existence. Therefore His essence is His existence. Thirdly, because, just as that which has fire, but is not itself fire, is on fire by participation; so that which has existence but is not existence, is a being by participation. But God is His own essence, as shown above (A[3]) if, therefore, He is not His own existence He will be not essential, but participated being. He will not therefore be the first being---which is absurd. Therefore God is His own existence, and not merely His own essence." St Thomas 
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3507  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: A Quote on Grace and Free Will... Discuss on: May 01, 2010, 11:37:56 AM
There is a distinct paradigm advancing in this christian life. I think we get off when we are not entirely convinced of these arguments in their particular application as individuals on this narrow road. This is why we are to seek peace for our selves and for our particular place of frequency. But there is no governing moral principle. We are not necessarily seeking peace but in seeking God we find peace. So that we can be deceived in finding a system of man in this incomplete peace that should mark our path.
Because the world is a place where authority is achieved in some human method and dominance. I think after much meditation that its main philosophy is drawn from the principle that all men fail in the addiction. And this is that law unto the self. Our particular epistemology will change as we develop into a mature christian. Because at some point we must proceed from a knowledge of a thing to the actual communication of persons. And this is why we are required to always be learning and applying new wisdom. Yesterdays case study is old....its old wine skins. We find more intuitiveness when we argue as we are infused with a new grace that brings more supernatural communications in the new morning in this present wisdom!
There are all kinds of methods that men devise to make it appear they are the moral example. Now we have agencies developing the public image of men both in the world and in the religious profession. We learn these artistic methods out of a lack of understanding of the nature and causes of the bigness of God. So that there is always a new form that is created by that public image as the answer to these schemes that men live in based upon being a law unto themselves.
We fail to take into account the stability of the natural disposition from the essence of things. There is a meta physical mystery that demands our present attention to detail and not a general moral examination of the sorrows and problems of this world. Because there are some men who do not have a problem with addictions. They are able to quit things because of this individual essence that is mysteriously part of their particular disposition strengths. Plus we fail to take into account that grace is like a universal power to produce effects that are tied to detail and not a general tendency in a society. There are much deeper truths here in getting to the real causes of the troubles of this life.    
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3508  Forums / Main Forum / Re: so, what's so good about Good Friday? on: May 01, 2010, 08:12:37 AM

His intelligence for my ignorance

Self denial is not giving up something in order to know what is true. It is not revealing secrets in order to be free from some kind of blind spot imagination. It is seeing that Gods work is 100 percent and our work is 100 percent ... or He works in us to will and do. Self denial is seeing that we put no confidence in our numbering system of checks and balances. In coming to terms with ourselves we focus on the causes of why we are not the same. It is seeing that our past sins have been taken care of out of the free grace of God from eternity past as our confidence that we forget about who we are now as we think of the reality of our struggle with our past sins. Because our relationship with our Father is much greater than our sins.

This is why we think in terms of what our identity is in light of the glory of Christ ... that we are new because He has given us power according to His concern for His name. Now that we have a new King we are represented in this new authority. He is both our high priest .. our prophet king. We are not trying to gain favor. Grace is what we live in. This is not a second chance. It is seeing that we determine only what He determined. We cannot do anything that He did not choose us to do. Because He is free to decide then we are free to have confidence that what we want is what He wants. It is this expression that we learn what true freedom is. 
ReplyReply Reply with quoteQuote Notify of repliesNotify
3509  Forums / Theology Forum / Re: Cursing Legalism on: April 30, 2010, 07:17:49 PM
If i were to compare the power of sin with the power of the flesh it may be like dealing with a reflection of my view of the powers of this world... and the devil. In a sense these overlap because they are all enemies of the soul. Just like this universe is mixed with beauty and danger. The problems come when we are having to face these enemies in a more profound way. This is what the apostle called the war on the inside. It is no wonder he used the term put to death because there is no other way to deal with this adversity and the fall out of its reducing a man to a mere animal.

I have found that there is a correlation between what a man knows and understands in a spiritual way and this free expression of victory in the temporary death of the experiencing of the power of these enemies. When i mean temporary death i mean experiencing a state of peace as if the victory in battle had ended the enemies threats. This knowledge and understand is about the epistemology of the use of the means in order to fight and not miss. It is also an awareness of the power of God available as a vehicle and not a intrinsic confusion of our image with His brightness in His glory. This is why there is no power in the flesh. This is why the apostle made it impossible for us to imagine that Christ had left a small amount of the flesh as alive to fight with our own ability.

If we were to turn on the microphone of the flesh we would discover that it is not interested in a slow and subtle movement. It is screaming curses in our spiritual ears. If you thought about a situation that is so hideous and hateful then it would be confronted by someone who was threatening us and cursing at us. This is the level of the anxiety that we endure in growing to understand the nature of all of these powers as what our present spiritual awareness affords us. Think about this. Its not a physical attentiveness. You speak in a way of understanding along with petitions to our Father.. that will kill its voice. Peace that passeth understanding.

Most of the opposition in this world that affect us is done at a distance and out of our site so that it does not occur to us that we are being opposed. Then the bible tells us that we become aware of this opposition on the day of battle. This is what brings us a certain conflict in a direct sense. This is how it is in our souls as well. Its always present and its always working in a way that we are caught in the middle between self confidence and presuppositions and our general disposition as it relates to our present understanding in contrast to our joy and praise.This is why the flesh is so subtle because it is screaming at us from a distance... i mean... because we do not always know how attentive we should be to the voice of our Shepherd. Because in dealing with the flesh our view must be through the eyes of faith. In other words in looking at the power of the flesh through the eyes of faith we are always aware that the day of battle is approaching. Because all of these pre ordained paradigms to make all things good are represented in our level of attentiveness to the Shepherds warnings and comforts in the Spirit. Those who know how loud the curses can become know that they are always to be on guard. That is just because we do not experience these powerful enemies when it is as strong as on the day of battle we.... subdue it for the day of battle by the word and Spirit in order that we will fight when it speaks the loudest.  

No comments:

Post a Comment